Beer & Food


Brews - $6.00/Specialty Drinks - $7.00

Beer Flight – 4 samples with souvenir glass.

Frog Hollow Pale Ale – 5.5% abv. – 23 IBU – 13.3 Plato
American-Style Pale Ale brewed with 2-row base malt with English Crystal malt for a nice caramel flavor and a pinch of Black malt.

Turtle Crawl Porter – 6.6% abv. – 33 IBU – 15 Plato
American-Style Ruby Porter brewed with 2-row base malt, chocolate malt for dark depths of flavor and Finger Lakes Coffee Roasters coffee is added to the brew kettle which helps make this a true regional delight.

Gully Washer IPA – 6.0% abv. – 54 IBU – 13.9 Plato
American-Style IPA brewed with 2-row base malt and just enough dark CaraMunich malt to give it some body and a dark straw color.

Draft of the Day
We choose a regional craft brew as our special draft to round out our selection.

Bottled Beer – Empire Brewing Skinny Atlas Light

Mulled Wine – Rhine Street Red Wine warmed with mulling spices. A toasty treat! (Winter months only)

Wine Slushy  – Rhine Street Red Wine, Healthy Purple Grape Juice and Lemonade. (Summer months only)

Hard Cider – Hazlitt Cider Tree

Bourbon Cream Bomber – Black Button Bourbon with Root Beer

Peach Buzz – Ice tea cocktail with Black Button Gin

Raspberry Buzz –  Ice tea cocktail with Black Button Vodka

Gluten Free GF

Gluten free? YES! All of our locally made brats are gluten free with the exception of our Sherried Wine Sausage. The delicious Winemaster’s Sauerkraut, and our German Potato Salad are also both gluten free.

Vegetarian  V 

Vegetarian offerings include a tofurkey beer brat that is so good you may want a second one! Our acclaimed Cheese Pasta Salad made with our Black Raspberry Celery Seed Dressing is another vegetarian offering. Enjoy a cup or a bowl!

Brats - $7.50 * Steak Night

(All Brats will be served in a roll unless requested in a wrap)

Arbor Hill Sherried Wine Sausage (Mild)
Pork and veal are marinated with Arbor Hill Sherried Wine BBQ sauce to produce a truly unique & flavorful wine-based sausage.

Bristol Brat (Mild)
A savory herbal Austrian style brat; a blend of pork, onion, Garlic and fresh herbs; Parsley & Oregano. GF

Apricot/Cranberry Brat (Mild)
With both apricots and cranberries this sausage is the perfect mixture of sweet and tart. GF

Chicken Supremo (Medium-Hot)
This brat has a combination of customary Italian seasonings. It is a healthy substitute for traditional sausage that only has 90 calories/serving. GF

Andouille (Hot)
This Cajun pork sausage is smoked and seasoned with garlic, paprika and a variety of peppers for a hot spicy flavor. GF

Hartmann’s Frankfurter (Mild)
Our pork and beef Frankfurters offer a quality alternative to the average American hot dog. Lightly smoked and mildly seasoned, the Frankfurters have a well-rounded flavor. GF

Vegetarian Beer Brat (Mild)
Tofurky® Beer Brats are the first vegetarian meat that actually SIZZLE on the grill and really fill out a bun with mustard and sauerkraut. Made with microbrewed and real tofu, these Beer Brats are certified vegan, satisfying and delicious. GF V

Brat Sampler Platter -$29.95
5 Brats Sliced Appetizer-style, Fresh Baked Roll & a bowl of your favorite side

Steak Night – Friday Only, 5 -8pm, Reservations Encouraged 585-531-4113

The Steak Wagon features Certified Black Angus Beef, a choice of two delectable sides and a beverage of your choice. We feature 3 regional steak sauces to top off your steak, including Arbor Hill’s Cracked Peppercorn Finishing Sauce. 

Single Steak Meal – $29.95

Steak for Two – $50.00







Red Wines - $5.50 / glass

(Listed Dry to Sweet)

Diana (Blush)
Rhine Street Red
Griesa Hill Iona (Rose’)
Very Cranberry
Very Blueberry
Sparkling Wines
Sparkling Chardonnay

White Wines - $5.50 / glass

(Listed Dry to Sweet)

Moores Diamond
Dry Traminette
Classic Traminette
Onnalinda White
Rhine Street White
Ogarita Niagara
Speedster Noiret




Grape Tart – $2.00
Brownie – $3.00
Katie’s Chocolate Chip Cookie – $3.00
Chocolate Chip Ice Cream Sandwich – $3.75
Brew & Brats Chocolate Candy Bar – $3.00
Chocolate Cabernet Ice Cream – Vanilla ice cream topped with Arbor Hill Chocolate Cabernet Wine Sauce – $2.50
Turtle Crawl Porter Float – $7.00


Winemaster’s Sauerkraut – Cup – $2.50 or Bowl – $5.00
This famous kraut is what everyone is talking about. We have several unique ingredients; Arbor Hill Wine, Pineapple, Bacon and Juniper berries. You just have to try it! GF

Cheese Pasta Salad – Cup – $2.50 or Bowl – $5.00
Made with Arbor Hill’s Black Raspberry Celery Seed dressing, spiral pasta, olives, peppers, onions, and feta cheese. V   ( Summer months only.)

Meat & Bean Chili – Cup – $2.50 or Bowl – $5.00                        Made with Arbor Hill Black Peppercorn Finishing Sauce. (Winter months only.)

German Potato Salad – Cup – $2.50 or Bowl – $5.00
Made with Arbor Hill’s Sun-Dried Tomato Vinaigrette. GF

Route 11 Potato Chips – $2.50
These potato chips are handmade in small batches. They are actually better for you than regular kettle chips. We offer (BBQ, Dill, Sour Cream & Chive, Salt & Vinegar, and Lightly Salted)

Non-Alcoholic Beverages - $2

Homemade Root Beer
Bottled Water
Diet Coke
Healthy Purple Grape Juice
Arbor Hill Sweetened Flavored Iced Tea



Bottles, Pitchers and Growlers

Pitcher of Craft Beer – $16.95
Pitcher of Root Beer – $10.95
Wine by the Bottle – $9.95 – $19.95
Growler of Beer – $16.95 Refill – $11.95
Growler of Root Beer – $10.95 Refill – $5.95


Fresh Baked Roll w/butter $1.50
Dill Pickle – $1.00
Pickled Egg – $1.00
Pretzel Bites – $4.00
Cheese & Cracker Platter – $13.95
 (Cheese, Beef Stick & Crackers)

Prices subject to change without notice.


Tribute to the Winemaster.